Explanatory Notes
Headnote
Apparatus Notes
Guide
MTPDocEd
Autobiographical Dictation, 3 October 1906 ❉ Textual Commentary

Source documents.

TS1 ribbon      Typescript, leaves numbered 1297–1305, made from Hobby’s notes and revised.
TS1 carbon      Typescript carbon, leaves numbered 1297–1305, revised.

Clemens lightly revised TS1 ribbon, then transferred most of his revisions to TS1 carbon. He then further revised TS1 carbon with the intention of including it in an NAR installment, but it was never published there. Several revisions, made to protect Clara’s privacy and to suppress Susan Crane’s name, have been rejected from the present text. He evidently planned to use this dictation to follow an excerpt from the AD of 6 December 1906, the anecdote about Clara’s bravery when her finger was injured. Ultimately the entire AD of 6 December was published in NAR 14, where it was combined with excerpts from several other dictations (see the Textual Commentary).

Marginal Notes on TS1 carbon Concerning Publication in NAR

Location on TS Writer, Medium Exact Inscription Explanation
TS1 carbon, p. 1897 SLC, ink 2
Add this after “nobody braver but God?”
use as the second section of the NAR installment, which should begin with an excerpt from the AD of 6 Dec 1906 about Clara’s bravery
TS1 carbon, p. 1897 SLC, ink Use it all. (about 7 pages.  
TS1 carbon, p. 1897 SLC, ink 1¾ R. pages 3½ R. pages number of NAR pages
[begin page 240]
Wednesday, October 3, 1906textual note

Clara Clemens’s débuttextual note in Norfolk, Connecticuttextual note—The episode of her crib catching fire when she was seven yearstextual note old—The two other fires on the two following days—Rosa’s promptness in rescuing the children—Rosa’s marriage, and her experience with the scarecrow and the crows.

Yesterday I mentioned that on the 22dtextual note of September I went up to Norfolk, Connecticut, from New York, and witnessed my daughter Clara’s débuttextual note as a singer. She had sung in public once before, but that was in Italytextual note explanatory note in a class of a dozen other girls—a music teacher’s exhibition—and of course the house was full of approving and uncritical papas and mammas and brothers and sisters and aunts and cousins and uncles, and it was not a real débuttextual note, and had few of the terrors of a real débuttextual note. It was two years and a half ago. In Norfolk Clara was two-thirds of the entire show. The other third consisted, according to custom,textual note of interlardings of instrumental music.textual note She showed good nerve. She was frozen stiff with stage-frighttextual note, but it was not detectable.

She always had plenty of nerve. I think I have several times touched upon this fact in earlier chapters. Once when she was seven years oldtextual note she came near being burnt up one morning, but she was more interested in the tumult and excitement than she was in the danger. As far as the peril was concerned, she was as indifferent as if she had a paid-uptextual note fire policy on her life. She had the diphtheria, and had been removed to our room so that her mother might have her under her eye all the time. She was in her crib, and over the crib had been built a tent of blankets; on the floor was an alcohol lamp, which supplied heat to a vessel filled with lactic acid and lime; from this vessel a spout discharged the medicated steam into the tent. It was early morning. The season was winter, and the weather was very cold. Mrs. Clemens left the room for a moment, and then one of those accidents happenedtextual note which had been decreed by Adam’s first act—or, at any rate, was an unavoidable result of that act.textual note Thetextual note lamp set the blanket-tent and the bedding on fire. Rosa, the German nurse, entered at that moment. The flames were streaming up round about the child, but that did not make Rosa lose her head—nothing ever did, during the twelve years that she was in our service. She went at the work of rescue with that fine intelligence which begins at the right end instead of the wrong end. She first snatched Clara from the crib and put her on the bed; then shetextual note flung up a window; nexttextual note she gathered the burning tent in her hands and carried it there and flung it out;textual note next she carried the burning mattress and bedding to the window and threw them out; finally she enveloped the child in wraps. She did all these things in their proper order, giving each service its right and proper place in the list. Rosa was a swift person, and she accomplished these several things in about the space of time it would have taken me to think out one of them and start out to hunt up somebody to do it. Clara was not badly scorched, and she enjoyed all the details of the stirring incident. (Thistextual note was Rosa’s testimony.)textual note She also [begin page 241] enjoyed the tumult and the excited ejaculations which followed when her mother and I and the entire household, big and little, swarmed into the room a few moments later. We got the impression that she would like to have it all done over again.

While I am back in that distant time I will go on and tell about what happened the next morning, and the morning after. On the first of these two mornings Jean, a baby of one year’s experience of life, was asleep in her crib in the nursery, under a tall canopy of flimsy white muslin, or some such material. The crib was in front of a brisk wood fire,textual note and the whole fireplace-fronttextual note was covered by a spark-arrester in the form of a screen of fine copper wires—wires that were so close together that you could hardly insert a knife-blade between them—nevertheless a spark was discharged through this obstruction, and it lit on the slope of that canopy and set it afire. It was about breakfast-time,textual note and no one was in the room. The Polish wet-nurseexplanatory note ought to have been there, but she wasn’t; she wasn’t, because Adam’s first act had created a chain of events which made it impossible for her to be there at that time.textual note But she presently entered and saw the canopy blazing up. She was not a Rosa, and she lost her head at once, what there was of it,textual note and went screaming out of the place. The screams brought Rosa, and she flew into the room and snatched Jean out and put her on the bed; next she ran and threw up a window;textual note then she carried the burning mattress and bed-clothes to the window and threw them out, along with what was left of the canopy; next she threw water on the crib and on the wood-work at the base of the wall—for both were on fire—and finally she clothed Jean in wraps, and was thentextual note all through and ready for the household to swarm in and make a tumult, as usual.

With the practice which Rosa had now accumulatedtextual note, she could have saved a child from a burning crib every morning for the rest of her life, and never put any detail of the incident in the wrong place in the list. Jean had suffered two or three burns, but they were of small consequence.

The next morning, just before breakfast-timetextual note, Susy, aged nine, was practisingtextual note at the piano in the schoolroomtextual note, which adjoined the nursery. At one end of the room a fire of large logs was burning. Susy was at the other end of the room with her back toward the fire. A log burned in two and the ends fell and scattered coals around about the heavy wood-work which supported the mantelpiece,textual note and set it on fire. Just at the right moment the barber entered that room. This had been made necessary and unavoidable by Adam’s first act, and could never have happened if Adam had done something other than the thing which he did do.textual note No one was likely to enter that room at that hour. The barber had never entered it before; he had always shaved me in a bedroomtextual note on the ground floor, but this time, in obedience to Adam’s arrangement,textual note that room was in possession of a guest, and George, the colored butlerexplanatory note, had sent the barber up to the schoolroomtextual note with instructions to abide there in peace until I should come. He made no outcry when he saw the flames climbing to the mantelpiece, but brought water from the nursery bath-roomtextual note and extinguished them. If Adamtextual note had delayed him even three or four minutes, the house could not have been saved.

Our family has never had many adventures, and so we have always set a high value on [begin page 242] the three which I have describedexplanatory note; and the value of them to us has been greatly enhanced by the fact that they were not scattered over a period of months or years, but all happened in a bunch in three consecutive days.

Rosa was a remarkable girl. She was very lively, and active, and spirited, with a strong sense of humor, and she had a rollicking laugh that came easily and was as catching as the smallpox. You would not expect such a character to be cool and prompt and effective in an emergency, but she was. I have not met her match for coolness and clear-headedness and wisdom in times of excitement and peril. Once when Clara was four years oldtextual note we were living for a time on the third floor of a hotel in Baden-Baden, and one morning a middle-aged German chambermaidtextual note appeared in our room, white-faced and trembling, and tried to tell us something, but was so frightened that she couldn’t speak. While we waited—which was the natural thing for ordinary people to do—Rosa didn’t, but slipped out, without a word, and found Clara entertaining herself in a most questionable way. She had crowded her small body through the pillarsexplanatory note of the marble balustrade,textual note and had thentextual note faced about and clasped her hands around a pillar, with her back overhanging the marble pavement of the lobby, three stories below. Rosa approached her nonchalantly, and said,textual note

“Wait here, Clärchentextual note, I am going to bring you something pretty—no, maybe I better take you with me. It is at the other end of the hall.”

Then she lifted the child over the balusters, brought her and delivered her into the arms of her mother, and then sat down and cried.

She saved Clara again the next summer, in America.textual note It was at the seaside,textual note and a number of children attended by their nurses were playing in the water. I was sitting on a little precipice twenty-five feet high overlookingtextual note the scene. Rosa and Susy were sitting on the sand at some little distance from Clara. A girl seven or eighttextual note years old began to splash water in Clara’s face; this bewildered the child and partially strangled her, and in struggling to get away from the persecution she fell on her face, and so remained, helplessly struggling.textual note Of course this meant death,textual note unless a rescue was prompt. The nursery maids stood appalled, and through fright they were not able to move a limb. There was no way for me to get down that precipice without breaking my neck. But after a moment Rosa sawtextual note what had happened,textual note and she came flying andtextual note rushed in and dragged the child ashore. Clara has had other alarming adventures by water, and if I had been the right kind of a father I would have taken out both fire and marine insurance on her long ago.

When Rosa had been with us twelve years she married a young farmerexplanatory note whose place was near Susy Crane’stextual note “Quarry Farm.” The couple put in a corn crop, and when it was sprouting the crows came and began to digtextual note up the result. There was no scarecrow, but Rosa had a superannuated old gingham umbrella, and she spread it and stuck it up amidst the corn-sproutstextual note for a scarecrowtextual note. Then she sat down on the porch very much pleased with her cunning idea. But there was a surprise awaiting her. It began to rain, and the crows pulled up the corn-sproutstextual note and took them under the umbrella to eat them!textual note Rosa’s sense of humor enabled her to enjoy that episode to the full.

Textual Notes Wednesday, October 3, 1906
  Wednesday, October 3, 1906 ●  Wednesday, Oct. 3, 1906. (TS1 ribbon)  Wednesday, Dictated Oct. 3, 1906. ‘Oct. 3’ underscored; dateline marked to precede ‘Yesterday’ at 240.6 (TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  début ●  de ébut accent added  (TS1 ribbon-SLC, TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  Connecticut ●  Conn. (TS1 ribbon, TS1 carbon) 
  seven years ●  7 yrs. (TS1 ribbon, TS1 carbon) 
  22d ●  22nd (TS1 ribbon, TS1 carbon) 
  début ●  de ébut accent added  (TS1 ribbon-SLC)  debut (TS1 carbon) 
  in Italy ●  in Italy  (TS1 ribbon-SLC, TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  début ●  de ébut accent added  (TS1 ribbon-SLC)  debut (TS1 carbon) 
  début ●  de ébut accent added  (TS1 ribbon-SLC)  debut (TS1 carbon) 
  consisted, according to custom, ●  consisted, according to custom,  (TS1 ribbon-SLC, TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  She . . . music. ●  She . . . music. (TS1 ribbon)  She . . . music. ‘Leave these 9 or 10 lines out.’ written in the margin  (TS1 carbon-SLC)  note that within the entries through 240.13, the readings of TS1 carbon are not represented as canceled
  stage-fright ●  stage fright (TS1 ribbon, TS1 carbon) 
  seven years old ●  seven years old | 1881 inserted in the margin  (TS1 ribbon-SLC)  seven years old | 1881 inserted and deleted in the margin  (TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  paid-up ●  not in  (TS1 ribbon)  paid-up  (TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  one of those accidents happened ●  one of those accidents happened (TS1 ribbon)  one of those an accidents happened:  (TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  which . . . act. ●  which . . . act. The (TS1 ribbon)  which . . . act. ‘strike out.’ written in the margin  (TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  The ●  The (TS1 ribbon)  T the (TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  snatched . . . she ●  not in  (TS1 ribbon)  snatched . . . she  (TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  next ●  then (TS1 ribbon)  then next  (TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  out; ●  out; next she snatched Clara from the crib and put her on the bed; (TS1 ribbon)  out; next she snatched Clara from the crib and put her on the bed;  (TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  (This ●  This (TS1 ribbon)  (This (TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  testimony.) ●  testimony. (TS1 ribbon)  testimony.)  (TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  fire, ●  fire,  (TS1 ribbon-SLC)  fire (TS1 carbon) 
  fireplace-front ●  fire- | place-front  (TS1 ribbon-SLC)  fireplace-front ‘fire- | place’ marked to close up  (TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  breakfast-time, ●  breakfast time,  (TS1 ribbon-SLC)  breakfast time (TS1 carbon) 
  wasn’t; she wasn’t, . . . time. ●  wasn’t; she wasn’t, . . . time. (TS1 ribbon-SLC)  wasn’t. ; she wasn’t . . . time. ‘strike out’ written in the margin  (TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  what there was of it, ●  not in  (TS1 ribbon)  what there was of it,  (TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  snatched . . . window; ●  straight to the window at the further end of it, which she threw up; then she rushed back and snatched Jean out and put her on the bed; (TS1 ribbon)  straight to the window at the further end of it, which she threw up; then she rushed back and snatched Jean out and put her on the bed; next she ran and threw up a window;  (TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  then ●  then  (TS1 ribbon-SLC, TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  accumulated ●  enjoyed, accumulated  (TS1 ribbon-SLC, TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  breakfast-time ●  breakfast-time (TS1 ribbon-SLC)  breakfast time (TS1 carbon) 
  practising ●  practicing (TS1 ribbon, TS1 carbon) 
  schoolroom ●  school- | room (TS1 ribbon, TS1 carbon) 
  mantelpiece, ●  mantelpiece,  (TS1 ribbon-SLC, TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  This . . . do. ●  This . . . do. (TS1 ribbon)  This . . . do. ‘strike out.’ and ‘Strike out’ written in the margin  (TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  bedroom ●  bed- | room (TS1 ribbon, TS1 carbon) 
  time, in . . . arrangement, ●  time, in . . . arrangement, (TS1 ribbon)  time, in . . . arrangement, ‘strike out’ written twice in the margin  (TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  schoolroom ●  school-room (TS1 ribbon, TS1 carbon) 
  bath-room ●  bathroom (TS1 ribbon, TS1 carbon) 
  Adam ●  Adam (TS1 ribbon)  Adam anything  (TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  four years old ●  four years old | 1878 inserted in the margin  (TS1 ribbon-SLC)  four years old | 1878 inserted and deleted in the margin  (TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  chambermaid ●  chamber-maid (TS1 ribbon)  chamber-maid marked to close up  (TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  balustrade, ●  balustrade,  (TS1 ribbon-SLC)  balustrade (TS1 carbon) 
  then ●  then  (TS1 ribbon-SLC, TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  said, ●  said,  (TS1 ribbon-SLC)  said (TS1 carbon) 
  Clärchen ●  Cla ärchen accent added  (TS1 ribbon-SLC, TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  America. ●  America. | 1878 9 inserted in the margin  (TS1 ribbon-SLC)  America. | 1878 9 inserted and deleted in the margin  (TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  seaside, ●  seaside, Hobby typed ‘seashore’ and then altered it on the typewriter to ‘seaside,’  (TS1 ribbon)  seash ide, imperfectly correctly on the typewriter; SLC clarified the word as ‘seaside’ and added a comma  (TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  overlooking ●  over- | looking (TS1 ribbon, TS1 carbon) 
  seven or eight ●  eight or nine (TS1 ribbon)  seven or eight or nine  (TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  face, . . . struggling. ●  face. , . . . struggling.  (TS1 ribbon-SLC, TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  death, ●  death,  (TS1 ribbon-SLC)  death (TS1 carbon) 
  saw ●  saw (TS1 ribbon)  saw followed by a canceled caret  (TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  happened, ●  happened,  (TS1 ribbon-SLC, TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  she came flying and ●  she  (TS1 ribbon-SLC)  she came flying and  (TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  Susy Crane’s ●  Susy Crane’s (TS1 ribbon)  Susy Crane’s delete mark written in the margin  (TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  began to dig ●  began to dig  (TS1 ribbon-SLC)  & began to dig  (TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  corn-sprouts ●  corn sprouts (TS1 ribbon)  corn-sprouts (TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  scarecrow ●  scarecrow SLC deleted ‘scarecrow’ and inserted ‘make-sh’; then he canceled the insertion and wrote ‘STET’ under the deleted ‘scarecrow’  (TS1 ribbon-SLC)  scarecrow (TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  corn-sprouts ●  corn-sprouts (TS1 ribbon-SLC, TS1 carbon-SLC) 
  them! ●  them. ! period mended to an exclamation point  (TS1 ribbon-SLC, TS1 carbon-SLC) 
Explanatory Notes Wednesday, October 3, 1906
 

I went up to Norfolk, Connecticut . . . She had sung in public once before, but that was in Italy] In late 1898 Clara changed her musical study from piano to voice, hoping to pursue a professional career as a mezzo-soprano. She gave her first recital on 22 January 1901 in Washington, D.C.; it went badly, one sympathetic reviewer blaming “stage fright” and “partial paralysis of the vocal cords” (“Music and the Drama,” Chicago Tribune, 23 Jan 1901, 7). The Italian concert Clemens mentions took place in Florence, on 8 April 1904. Clemens wrote Rogers that Clara “astonished the house—including me—with the richness & volume of her voice, & with her trained ability to handle it. It was a lone hand quite triumphantly played. The congratulations have been abundant & cordial” (12 Apr 1904 to Rogers, Salm, in HHR, 561). Clara’s Norfolk, Connecticut, performance of 22 September 1906 was her professional debut. She continued to give concerts (largely bankrolled by her father) over the next several years, but never pursued a professional career (5 Mar 1899 to James R. Clemens, CtHMTH; Hartford Courant: “Miss Clemens’s Debut,” 23 Jan 1901, 8; “Miss Clemens’s Success,” 3 May 1904, 5; “Miss Clemens Well Received,” 24 Sept 1906, 10; Shelden 2010, 173–75, 231–32, 345–46, 382).

 

Polish wet-nurse] Julia Koshloshky (22 Apr 1882 to OLC, CU-MARK).

 

George, the colored butler] George Griffin (see AutoMT1 , 583 n. 335.28–32).

 

we have always set a high value on the three which I have described] The first two incidents that Clemens describes occurred on 2 and 9 January 1881 (9 Jan 1881 to JLC, NPV). The third incident, involving the barber, is not mentioned in any 1881 letters.

 

on the third floor of a hotel in Baden-Baden . . . her small body through the pillars] This incident took place at the Hotel de France, where the Clemenses stayed in late July and early August 1878. Clara later reported the she had been on the sixth floor ( N&J2, 113–14, 367; CC 1931, 6).

 

she married a young farmer] Rosina Hay (1852?–1926) came to work for the Clemenses in 1874, and left on 16 August 1883 to prepare for her wedding. On 4 September she was married in Elmira’s Park Church to Horace K. Terwilliger. In 1909 he was a committee clerk for the New York State Assembly ( N&J2, 365 n. 33; Hartford Census 1880, 97:117C; Staver 1938, 34; Koenig 1909, 591; AutoMT1 , 607 n. 394.15–18).