Explanatory Notes
Headnote
Apparatus Notes
Guide
MTPDocEd
Autobiographical Dictation, 6 October 1908 ❉ Textual Commentary

Source document.

TS      Typescript, six unnumbered leaves, made from Howden’s notes and revised.

TS, as revised by Clemens, is the only authoritative source for this dictation. It is the first typescript that Mary Louise Howden made from Clemens’s dictation (see AD, 6 Oct 1908, note at 267 title). (It is also the first of several typescripts for which she used a typewriter with a small typeface equipped with a purple ribbon; she had typed the manuscripts comprising AD, 16 July and 12 September 1908, on a machine with a larger typeface using a black ribbon.) The punctuation of TS is sparse, and Clemens added to it in revising. Howden later recalled that this was Clemens’s preference: “He put in the punctuation himself. His stenographer was never allowed to add so much as a comma” (Howden 1925). At the top of the first page Clemens wrote ‘Get the paging from Miss Lyon, & add it.’—apparently an instruction (not followed) to continue the numbering sequence of TS1, which had ended on 14 July with page 2597.

[begin page 267]
Dictated at Stormfield, October 6textual note, 1908explanatory note

I called this house Innocence at Home but my daughter Clara has abolished that name and replaced it with Stormfield.textual note This is well,textual note and is satisfactory to me;textual note for the whole strain of furnishing innocence enough to justify the other name was falling upon me,textual note and was already beginning to tax me beyond my strength. The house stands high and lonely and exposed to all the winds that blow; consequently Stormfield is a rational name for it; besides,textual note the loggia and thetextual note apartment over it,textual note which is Clara’s,textual note was not to have been built until next year or the year after,textual note for economic reasons; buttextual note when we found we could add it at oncetextual note without expense,textual note we added it. It cost us nothing because I got all oftextual note the necessary money for ittextual note out of a small manuscript which had lain in my pigeon-holestextual note forty-one years,textual note and which I sold to Harper’s Magazine textual note. The article was entitled “Captaintextual note Stormfield’s Visit to Heaven.”textual note explanatory note So I think that on the whole Stormfield is a more logical and more justifiable name than the other one.

Lately Stormfield has distinguished itself by getting broken into by burglars. It seems strange to me that a New York architect should have overlooked so glaring a necessity as a burglar alarmtextual note for so isolated a house as this is,textual note when I reflecttextual note that New York is only an hour and a half away;textual note that it contains four millions of people,textual note and that the most of them are burglars. It would not have occurred to me to employ a dog,textual note because a dog barks; he barks at anything and everything that comes along,textual note and therefore is a nuisance; of course hetextual note would bark at atextual note burglar, andtextual note I would rather have the burglar.

The house was entered at half past twelve,textual note midnight,textual note eighteen days ago. There were two burglars and they entered by the cellar door and came up to the dining roomtextual note on the ground floor. Nobody sleeps on that floor, all the household sleep on the second floor. The burglars made a good deal of noiseexplanatory note,textual note but disturbed the sleep of no one but Miss Lyon my secretary. She went down stairstextual note and discovered the burglars and shouted for the butlerexplanatory note;textual note the burglarstextual note disappeared at once through the dining roomtextual note door,textual note which they had opened for their convenience. They had already carried away some silver to the entrance gate,textual note and had come back for the rest.

Here we have the whole reason for a burglar alarm:textual note the whole function of a burglar alarm is to alarm burglars. It does it.textual note The moment the burglartextual note hears it begin to buzz he drops everything and flies. There was never yet a burglar who would remain after the alarm began its office,textual note and there was never a burglar who would enter a house which he knew possessed an alarm. We are having an alarm put in now. A little late, but worth while.textual note

Miss Lyon telephoned Mr. Lounsbury,textual note our nearest neighborexplanatory note; hetextual note telephonedtextual note Deputy-Sheriff Banks,textual note who lives six miles away,textual note and by a trifle after one o’clock both were here and ready for business. They set out upon the trail of the burglars,textual note accompanied by Mr. Warkexplanatory note and the butler—textual notea trail easy to follow by help of a lantern,textual note because the dust was deep in the road and the burglars kept to the road instead of breaking for the woods. Following a trail by lantern light is slow work; it led the searchers a plodding and wearytextual note [begin page 268] six miles,textual note to a railway station. Presently a train came along and the searchers and the burglars boarded it simultaneously, the burglars from the one side,textual note the searchers from the other. It was an accommodation train that carries almost exclusively people with whose faces the conductor is familiar. The Sheriff asked the conductor if he had any strangers aboard. He said he had only two,textual note and pointed them out. The pair sat together,textual note with a small hand-bag between them—textual notea hand-bag with our silver in it,textual note as it happened. When a highwayman accosts you in the way of business he says,textual note “holdtextual note up your hands!”textual note but when Sheriff Banks accosted this couple he changed that,textual note and said “holdtextual note up your feet!”textual note for he wanted to see if their unimmortal soles corresponded to the footprintstextual note he had been following. His remark was quite enough for the burglars,textual note and they made a spring for freedom. A scuffle followed,textual note in which one burglar fought his way to the rear of the car and jumped from the moving train unhurt by the pistol-shotstextual note which Mr. Wark sent after him;textual note meantime thetextual note Sheriff had the other burglar down on the floor,textual note and he secured him at cost of getting a bullet in his thightextual note and another one in the rest of his leg. An hour later the escaped burglar was captured. Both are in jail now,textual note awaiting trial.

All the silver they had taken was in that hand-bag,textual note and therefore we got it back. They had taken double as much plated ware; but they were old and experiencedtextual note New York cracksmen,textual note and as soon as dawn enabled them to examine it they recognizedtextual note its character and hid it in the grass by the roadside,textual note where it was found ten days later. I suppose one ought to feel sorry for these men,textual note for they must spend about fifteen years in a penitentiary for their adventure yet they got nothing at all for the trouble they took.

But I will reserve my compassion,textual note because certain aspects of this case have changed my mind about burglary, and have brought me to consider it a very high crime,textual note even when the burglartextual note inflictstextual note bodily harm upon no one when committing it. In the course of thirty-five years of experience as a householder I have been visited in the night several times by burglars. They took whatever was handy and went away without disturbing us,textual note andtextual note we were unawaretextual note that anything had happened—textual notein all but one instance—textual noteuntil the next morning;textual note and so the impression left behind them was not discomforting. No onetextual note in the housetextual note was in the least degree disturbed by the incident.textual note I think,textual note now,textual note the saving thing was that they made no alarming noise. The present case was different. The heedless creatures woke up Miss Lyon,textual note and she woke up the whole household except me. That was eighteen days ago,textual note and I am the only member of the household that has had any valuable sleep since. Clara fled to New York, finding she could get no sleep here; Miss Lyon’s nights are mainly sleepless; four days ago the butler gave up trying to sleep,textual note and took his departure; the cook and thetextual note maids handed in their resignations the next dayexplanatory note; yesterday one of the maids who has been with us four years,textual note and was expecting to remain with us forty,textual note resigned her position and told me that since the burglary she never gets more than three hours of sleep at one stretch, and whethertextual note the stretch be short or long she wakes out of it with a shriek and sits up in bed delivering cold perspiration from every pore—textual noteand always because of one and the same dream,textual note repeated and repeated over and over again night after night,textual note in which dream the burglars are always shooting her to death and she feels the bullets go through her. Since the burglary I have conversed with many persons [begin page 269] who have had personal experience of burglaries,textual note and I find that when the burglar makes a noise and frightens the women-folktextual note of the household it takes those women years to get over the effects of it. For many months their sleep,textual note when they get any,textual note is filled with horrors,textual note and their lives are made miserable. As I have already said,textual note this new light makes burglary, to me, a particularly high crime—textual notea much higher crime than it would be if the burglar had killed thetextual note sufferer; for death is much better than a life filled with terror.

And so,textual note if I were privileged to alter the law,textual note I would maketextual note the penaltytextual note light for noiseless burglary,textual note and remorselesslytextual note hang the burglar who disturbed the peace of the family.

A couple of days after the burglary I put a notice on the front door. By the letters which are arriving now,textual note I find that it has traveled through the European newspapers,textual note and as it had already traveledtextual note through the American ones I think that most of the burglars of this world have read it and will see the wisdom of allowing themselves to be guided by it.


NOTICE.

To the next Burglar. explanatory note


There is nothing but plated ware in this house, now and henceforth. You will find it in that brass thing in the dining roomtextual note over in the corner by the basket of kittens. If you want the basket, put the kittens in the brass thing. Do not make a noise—textual noteit disturbs the family. You will find rubbers in the front hall, by that thing which has the umbrellas in it, chiffonier, I think they call it, or pergola, or something like that.

Please close the doortextual note when you go away.textual note

Very truly yours,

S. L. Clemens.

Textual Notes Dictated at Stormfield, October 6, 1908
  October 6 ●  Oct. 6th (TS) 
  Stormfield. ●  Stormfield. This is well enough.  (TS-SLC) 
  well, ●  well, enough,  (TS-SLC) 
  me; ●  me;  (TS-SLC) 
  me, ●  me,  (TS-SLC) 
  besides, ●  besides,  (TS-SLC) 
  the ●  the  (TS-SLC) 
  it, ●  it,  (TS-SLC) 
  Clara’s, ●  Clara’s (TS) 
  after, ●  after,  (TS-SLC) 
  reasons; but ●  reasons; . B but period mended to a semicolon  (TS-SLC) 
  at once ●  without delay and at once  (TS-SLC) 
  expense, ●  expense,  (TS-SLC) 
  all of ●  all of  (TS-SLC) 
  for it ●  for it  (TS-SLC) 
  pigeon-holes ●  pigeon-holes  (TS-SLC) 
  years, ●  years,  (TS-SLC) 
  Harper’s Magazine  ●  Harper’s Magazine (TS) 
  “Captain ●  Captain (TS-SLC) 
  Heaven.” ●  Heaven.  (TS-SLC) 
  burglar alarm ●  burglar-alarm (TS-SLC) 
  is, ●  is. ,  (TS-SLC) 
  when I reflect ●  But I have when I reflected  (TS-SLC) 
  away; ●  away; semicolon mended to a colon  (TS-SLC) 
  people, ●  people,  (TS-SLC) 
  dog, ●  dog,  (TS-SLC) 
  along, ●  along,  (TS-SLC) 
  he ●  then he (TS-SLC) 
  a ●  the a  (TS-SLC) 
  burglar, and ●  burglar. , and  (TS-SLC) 
  twelve, ●  twelve,  (TS-SLC) 
  midnight, ●  midnight,  (TS-SLC) 
  dining room ●  diningroom (TS) 
  noise, ●  noise,  (TS-SLC) 
  down stairs ●  downstairs (TS) 
  butler; ●  butler; who came  (TS-SLC) 
  burglars ●  burglars  (TS-SLC) 
  dining room ●  diningroom (TS) 
  door, ●  door,  (TS-SLC) 
  gate, ●  gate,  (TS-SLC) 
  alarm: ●  alarm; :  (TS-SLC) 
  it. ●  alarm him. it.  (TS-SLC) 
  the burglar ●  the burglar  (TS-SLC) 
  office, ●  office,  (TS-SLC) 
  A little late, but worth while. ●  A little late, but worth while.  (TS-SLC) 
  Lounsbury, ●  Lounsbury,  (TS-SLC) 
  neighbor; he ●  neighbor; . H he period mended to a semicolon  (TS-SLC) 
  telephoned ●  telephoned to  (TS-SLC) 
  Banks, ●  Banks,  (TS-SLC) 
  away, ●  away,  (TS-SLC) 
  burglars, ●  burglars,  (TS-SLC) 
  butler— ●  butler— typed hyphen retraced to make a dash  (TS-SLC) 
  lantern, ●  lantern,  (TS-SLC) 
  a plodding and weary ●  a plodding and weary  (TS-SLC) 
  miles, ●  miles,  (TS-SLC) 
  side, ●  side,  (TS-SLC) 
  two, ●  two,  (TS-SLC) 
  together, ●  together,  (TS-SLC) 
  them— ●  them— typed hyphen retraced to make a dash  (TS-SLC) 
  it, ●  it,  (TS-SLC) 
  says, ●  says,  (TS-SLC) 
  “hold ●  hold (TS-SLC) 
  hands!” ●  hands!  (TS-SLC) 
  that, ●  that,  (TS-SLC) 
  “hold ●  hold (TS-SLC) 
  feet!” ●  feet, !”  (TS-SLC) 
  footprints ●  foot- | prints (TS-SLC) 
  burglars, ●  burglars,  (TS-SLC) 
  followed, ●  followed,  (TS-SLC) 
  pistol-shots ●  pistol shots (TS) 
  him; ●  him. ; period mended to a semicolon  (TS-SLC) 
  meantime the ●  meantime T the (TS-SLC) 
  floor, ●  floor,  (TS-SLC) 
  thigh ●  side thigh  (TS-SLC) 
  now, ●  now,  (TS-SLC) 
  hand-bag, ●  hand-bag,  (TS-SLC) 
  experienced ●  competent experienced  (TS-SLC) 
  cracksmen, ●  cracksmen,  (TS-SLC) 
  recognized ●  recognised (TS) 
  roadside, ●  roadside,  (TS-SLC) 
  men, ●  men,  (TS-SLC) 
  compassion, ●  compassion,  (TS-SLC) 
  crime, ●  crime,  (TS-SLC) 
  the burglar ●  they burglar  (TS-SLC) 
  inflicts ●  inflict s  (TS-SLC) 
  us, ●  us,  (TS-SLC) 
  and ●  and so  (TS-SLC) 
  unaware ●  unaware , until morning,  (TS-SLC) 
  happened— ●  happened— typed hyphen retraced to make a dash  (TS-SLC) 
  instance— ●  instance— typed hyphen retraced to make a dash  (TS-SLC) 
  morning; ●  morning;  (TS-SLC) 
  No one ●  No-one (TS-SLC) 
  house ●  household  (TS-SLC) 
  the incident. ●  it. the incident.  (TS-SLC) 
  think, ●  think,  (TS-SLC) 
  now, ●  now,  (TS-SLC) 
  Lyon, ●  Lyon,  (TS-SLC) 
  ago, ●  ago,  (TS-SLC) 
  sleep, ●  sleep,  (TS-SLC) 
  the ●  the  (TS-SLC) 
  years, ●  years,  (TS-SLC) 
  forty, ●  forty,  (TS-SLC) 
  whether ●  if whether  (TS-SLC) 
  pore— ●  pore— typed hyphen retraced to make a dash  (TS-SLC) 
  dream, ●  dream,  (TS-SLC) 
  night, ●  night,  (TS-SLC) 
  burglaries, ●  burglaries,  (TS-SLC) 
  women-folk ●  women- | folk (TS) 
  sleep, ●  sleep,  (TS-SLC) 
  any, ●  any,  (TS-SLC) 
  horrors, ●  horrors,  (TS-SLC) 
  said, ●  said,  (TS-SLC) 
  crime— ●  crime— typed hyphen retraced to make a dash  (TS-SLC) 
  the ●  that the  (TS-SLC) 
  so, ●  so,  (TS-SLC) 
  law, ●  law,  (TS-SLC) 
  make ●  make ‖ make  (TS-SLC) 
  penalty ●  pnalty (TS) 
  burglary, ●  burglary,  (TS-SLC) 
  remorselessly ●  I would remorselessly (TS-SLC) 
  now, ●  now,  (TS-SLC) 
  newspapers, ●  newspapers,  (TS-SLC) 
  traveled ●  traveled (TS-SLC) 
  dining room ●  diningroom (TS) 
  noise— ●  noise— typed hyphen retraced to make a dash  (TS-SLC) 
  Please close the door ●  Please close the door SLC underscored ‘PLEASE CLOSE THE DOOR’ and wrote in the margin, R Plain Roman lower-case italics no emphasis needed.’  (TS-SLC) 
  away. ●  away: .  (TS-SLC) 
Explanatory Notes Dictated at Stormfield, October 6, 1908
 

title Dictated at Stormfield, October 6, 1908] Between 14 July and 6 October, Clemens nearly stopped working on his autobiography, producing only two manuscripts—the one he began on 16 July and completed on 12 September, and the one he wrote on 16 August. On 28 July he commented on this period of low productivity in a letter to Jean: “I am doing very very very very little work. I am sorry, but I can’t help it—without an effort, & I have ceased from having a liking for efforts. I seem to greatly prefer cards, & billiards, & reading, & smoking, & lying around in the shade” (photocopy in CU-MARK). Two weeks later he wrote to Howells, “I have discharged my stenographer, & have entered upon a holiday whose other end is in the cemetery” (12 Aug 1908, NN-BGC). The Autobiographical Dictation of 14 July was the last one taken down by Josephine Hobby, who was dismissed on 4 August. The present dictation was recorded by a new employee, Mary Louise Howden (b. 1880?), whom Clemens found to be “competent & ladylike, & educated & agreeable” (12 Oct 1908 to JC, photocopy in CU-MARK; Scotland Census 1901, CSSCT1901:327; “Approximate Pay Roll March 1st ’07 to Feb’y 28th ’09,” Schedule 8 of “Accountants’ Statements and Schedules” 1909). Howden had replied to an advertisement in the New York Herald for a “beginner at stenography who is willing to work in the country.” She learned later that Clemens preferred someone inexperienced because “he dictated so slowly,” pausing so long between his sentences that “watchful waiting was more desired than rapid fire speed” (Saunders 1925). In her letter of application she wrote:

I have worked for a year in the office of the Y.W.C.A. in Paris and have just mastered the Remington machine as used in this country. I graduated from Pitmans school in London as a stenographer, one year ago but have worked only 6 months out of that year owing to my leaving Europe and coming to America. I am a Scotch girl, an Episcopalian, refined and well educated. (Howden to SLC, 23 Sept 1908, CU-MARK)

In 1925 Howden published a long and interesting article about her experience at Stormfield, describing Clemens’s habit of dictating either in his bedroom or in the billiard room, his deadpan style of dictating humorous remarks, and his preference for adding his own punctuation to the typescripts, not allowing his stenographer “to add so much as a comma” (Howden 1925). She worked for Clemens until February 1909, when she was replaced by William E. Grumman (see “The Ashcroft-Lyon Manuscript,” note at 367.25).

 

I got all of the necessary money for it . . . “Captain Stormfield’s Visit to Heaven.”] Although George Harvey of Harpers had rejected “Captain Stormfield’s Visit” in September 1906—facetiously calling the story “too damn godly for a secular paper like the Magazine”—he accepted it a year later for publication in Harper’s Monthly, where it appeared in two installments in December 1907 and January 1908 (Harvey to SLC, before 7 Sept 1906, NNC; SLC 1907–8; see AutoMT2 , 550–51 nn. 193.39–194.2, 194.17–18). In 1909 Clemens recalled, “I got out that rusty little batch of paper and counted the words and saw that there was enough of them to build the loggia; so I sent the ‘Visit’ to Harper’s Monthly and collected the money” (“Stormfield, Mark Twain’s New Country Home,” Country Life in America 15 [Apr 1909]: 607–11, 650–52). In February 1907 Sunderland, the builder, gave an estimate of $4,100 for the loggia; the addition of a sleeping porch for Clara on the upper level brought the total cost to $4,550. This figure is consistent with the amount that Clemens earned for the story: thirty cents a word for approximately fifteen thousand words (letters in CU-MARK: Sunderland to Howells and Stokes, 20 Feb 1908, enclosed with Howells and Stokes to SLC, 21 Feb 1908; Howells and Stokes to SLC, 23 Mar 1908).

 

The burglars made a good deal of noise] The burglary took place early in the morning of 18 September. For the burglars, Henry Williams and Charles Hoffman, see the Autobiographical Dictation of 12 November 1908, notes at 276.10 and 278.18–20.

 

the butler] Claude Beuchotte (see the note at 268.34–35).

 

Mr. Lounsbury, our nearest neighbor] Harry A. Lounsbury (1873–1938), listed in the Redding census as a “farmer,” was a “Jack of all trades” who supervised the construction of Stormfield and served as the overseer of the house and grounds, including its livery stable. Clemens relied on his “talents in many fields” ( Redding Census 1910, 127:7A; MTB , 3:1463; Find a Grave Memorial 2013a; Howells and Stokes to SLC, 19 July 1907, CU-MARK).

 

four days ago the butler gave up trying to sleep, and took his departure; the cook and the maids handed in their resignations the next day] According to Katy Leary (the family’s longtime housekeeper), Claude Joseph Beuchotte (b. 1877), the French butler, first worked for the Clemenses during their residence in Riverdale (1901–3). He was again employed at 21 Fifth Avenue on 1 May 1907, but was among the group of servants who left Stormfield on 1 October 1908. (In “The Ashcroft-Lyon Manuscript,” Clemens says the servants left because of Lyon, and not because of the burglary.) Claude returned in April 1909 and remained until Clemens’s death (“Approximate Pay Roll March 1st ’07 to Feb’y 28th ’09,” Schedule 8 of “Accountants’ Statements and Schedules” 1909; for the other servants see “The Ashcroft-Lyon Manuscript,” note at 337.26–27). Henry Rogers, Jr., later hired Beuchotte to manage the Tabitha Inn, the hotel that his father had built in Fairhaven, Massachusetts (Schmidt 2013b).

 

NOTICE. To the next Burglar] Seventeen-year-old Dorothy Sturgis, an angelfish who arrived for a visit on 18 September, inscribed this humorous instruction in ornamental letters on a large card (see the reproduction following page 300). Clemens described it in his Stormfield guestbook: “The illuminated ‘Notice to the Next Burglar,’ which hangs in the billiard room, is Dorothy’s work copied engrossed from my rude original” (CU-MARK; Lyon 1908, entry for 18 Sept; for Dorothy see AD, 17 Apr 1908, note at 220.40). Clemens also posted the text on his front door, and it became an enduring newspaper item (“Burglars Invade Mark Twain Villa,” New York Times, 19 Sept 1908, 9).