Explanatory Notes
Apparatus Notes
MTPDocEd
[begin page 192]
40. Letter from Carson City
3 February 1863

In all probability this letter was completed on Saturday evening, 31 January 1863, mailed to Virginia City the next day, and published in the Territorial Enterprise on Tuesday, February 3. (The paper did not publish on Mondays.) The text is preserved in a clipping in one of Clemens' scrapbooks.1 It is likely that this letter was the first piece to which Clemens signed the name “Mark Twain,” in which case his remark “I feel very much as if I had just awakened out of a long sleep” seems deeply appropriate. The appearance of the taciturn Joseph T. Goodman in Clemens' account of the trip to Carson City is also significant. As proprietor and senior editor of the Enterprise, Goodman shared responsibility for hiring Clemens and for establishing the journalistic policy that fostered his development as a reporter and humorist in Nevada. In fact, this early example of an out-of-town newspaper letter is a sign of Goodman's willingness to give Clemens great freedom. Clemens had served as local editor for only a month, but had already managed to persuade his boss to give him a vacation: “They let me go, about the first of the month, to stay twenty-four hours in Carson,” he reported to his family, “and I staid a week.”2 It was a productive week: in that time he wrote and sent three letters signed “Mark Twain.”

In 1863 the newspaper letter from distant points was a standard, often a rather personal, way of reporting the news. Clemens learned to use the form more inventively than most other reporters did. At his best, he could float bits of hard news in a strong current of personal narrative and imaginative comedy, and he soon achieved an appealing informality and a flexible medium which commanded a large audience. In 1865 Goodman would [begin page 193] agree to pay him $100 a month for a daily letter from San Francisco, and in 1866 the Sacramento Union and the San Francisco Alta California would commission him to write two long series of travel letters.3

To sustain the comedy and provide an element of continuity in such a letter, Clemens often employed a stooge who was sometimes purely imaginary, sometimes based on a real acquaintance. In reporting the proceedings of the Territorial Legislature in November and December 1862 Clemens had adopted a character called the Unreliable—in reality Clement T. Rice, his friend of at least a year's standing and a respected reporter for the Virginia City Union.4 On 23 December 1862, for instance, Clemens sent his paper an account of the postadjournment celebration held in Washoe City, and he said in part:

The supper and the champagne were excellent and abundant, and I offer no word of blame against anybody for eating and drinking pretty freely. If I were to blame anybody, I would commence with the Unreliable—for he drank until he lost all sense of etiquette. I actually found myself in bed with him with my boots on. However, as I said before, I cannot blame the cuss; it was a convivial occasion, and his little shortcomings ought to be overlooked.5

Rice, who was probably also the original of the character Boggs in Roughing It, was an especially good straight man because he was cheerfully willing to keep the game going—making the Reliable, or Mark Twain, his stooge in the columns of the Union. Rice was a thoroughly reputable figure in Nevada society: he was the registrar of the United States Land Office in Carson City from 1862 to 1864, and like Clemens he had prospected and staked out Nevada mining claims. In 1863 he was secretary of the Watson Consolidated Gold and Silver Mining Company. Reputed to have made a sizable fortune in Nevada, Rice later went into business in New York City. Clemens reported his presence there in March 1867.6

Editorial Notes
1 The dating is fully discussed in MTEnt , pp. 47–48.
2 Clemens to Jane Clemens and Pamela Moffett, 16 February 1863, CL1 , letter 65.
3 That is, the letters from the Sandwich Islands and the Holy Land.
4 The Unreliable appears in nine other pieces in the present collection: nos. 41, 42, 44, 46, 47, 50, 51, 53, and 57.
5 “A Big Thing in Washoe City,” reprinted from the Enterprise by the Placer County (Calif.) Courier, 17 January 1863, p. 3, quoted in MTNev , p. 227. The letter is scheduled to appear in the collection of social and political writings in The Works of Mark Twain.
6 “Resignation and Appointment,” Lyon County Sentinel, 16 July 1864, p. 2; Virginia City Territorial Enterprise, 3 April 1863, p. 3; “Old Washoeites,” ibid., 15 May 1869, p. 3; “ ‘Mark Twain’ in New York,” San Francisco Alta California, 28 March 1867, p. 1.
Textual Commentary

The first printing appeared in the Virginia City Territorial Enterprise, almost certainly on 3 February 1863. The only known copy of this printing, in a clipping in Scrapbook 4, p. 11, MTP, is copy-text.

[begin page 194]
Letter from Carson City

Carson, Saturday Night.

Eds. Enterprise: I feel very much as if I had just awakened out of a long sleep. I attribute it to the fact that I have slept the greater part of the time for the last two days and nights. On Wednesday, I sat up all night, in Virginia, in order to be up early enough to take the five o'clock stage on Thursday morning. I was on time. It was a great success. I had a cheerful trip down to Carson, in company with that incessant talker, Joseph T. Goodmanexplanatory note. I never saw him flooded with such a flow of spirits before. He restrained his conversation, though, until we had traveled three or four miles, and were just crossing the divide between Silver Cityexplanatory note and Spring Valleyexplanatory note, when he thrust his head out of the dark stage, and allowed a pallid light from the coach lamp to illuminate his features for a moment, after which he returned to darkness again, and sighed and said, “Damn it!” with some asperity. I asked him who he meant it fortextual note, and he said, “The weather out there.” As we approached Carson, at about half past seven o'clock, he thrust his head out again, and gazed earnestly in the direction of that city—after which he took it in again, with his nose very much frosted. He propped the end of that organ upon the end of his finger, and looked down pensively upon it—which had the effect of making him appear cross-eyed—and remarked, “O, damn it!” with great bitterness. I asked him what he was up to this time, and he said, “The cold, damp fog—it is worse than the weather.” This was his last. He never spoke again in my hearing. He went on over the mountains, [begin page 195] with a lady fellow-passenger from here. That will stop his clatter, you know, for he seldom speaks in the presence of ladies.

In the evening I felt a mighty inclination to go to a party somewhere. There was to be one at Governoremendation J. Neely Johnson'sexplanatory note, and I went there and asked permission to stand around awhile. This was granted in the most hospitable manneremendation, and visions of plain quadrilles soothed my weary soul. I felt particularly comfortable, for if there is one thing more grateful to my feelings than another, it is a new house—a large house, with its ceilings embellished with snowy mouldings; its floors glowing with warm-tinted carpets; with cushioned chairs and sofas to sit on, and a piano to listen to; with fires so arranged that you can see them, and know that there is no humbug about it; with walls garnished with pictures, and above all, mirrors, wherein you may gaze, and always find something to admire, you know. I have a great regard for a good house,emendation and a girlish passion for mirrors. Horace Smithexplanatory note, Esq., is also very fond of mirrors. He came and looked in the glass for an hour, with me. Finally, it cracked—the night was pretty cold—and Horace Smith's reflection was split right down the centre. But where his face had been, the damage was greatest—a hundred cracks converged from his reflected nose, like spokes from the hub of a wagon wheel. It was the strangest freak the weather has done this Winter. And yet the parlor seemed very warm and comfortable, too.

About nine o'clock the Unreliable came and asked Gov. Johnson to let him stand on the porch. That creature has got more impudence than any person I ever saw in my lifeemendation. Well, he stood and flattened his nose against the parlor window, and looked hungry and vicious —he always looks that way—until Col. Musserexplanatory note arrived with some ladies, when he actually fell in their wake and came swaggering in, looking as if he thought he had been anxiously expected. He had on my fine kid boots, and my plug hat and my white kid gloves, (with slices of his prodigious hands grinning through the bursted seams), and my heavy gold repeater, which I had been offered thousands and thousands of dollars for, many and many a time. He took these articles out of my trunk, at Washoe Cityexplanatory note, about a month ago, when we went out there to report the proceedings of the Conventionexplanatory note. The Unreliable intruded himself upon me in his cordial way, and said, “How are you, Mark, old boy? when d'you come down? It's brilliant, [begin page 196] ain't it? Appear to enjoy themselves, don'temendation they? Lend a fellowemendation two bits, can't you?” He always winds up his remarks that way. He appears to have an insatiable craving for two bits.

The music struck up just then, and saved me. The next moment I was far, far at sea in a plain quadrille. We carried it through with distinguished success; that is, we got as far as “balance around,” and “half-a-man-left,”explanatory note when I smelled hot whisky punch, or something of that nature. I tracked the scent through several rooms, and finally discovered the large bowl from whence it emanated. I found the omnipresent Unreliable there, also. He set down an empty goblet, and remarked that he was diligently seeking the gentlemen's dressing room. I would have shown him where it was, but it occurred to him that the supper table and the punch-bowl ought not to be left unprotected; wherefore, we staid there and watched them until the punch entirelyemendation evaporated. A servant came in then to replenish the bowl, and we left the refreshments in his charge. We probably did wrong, but we were anxious to join the hazy dance. The dance was hazier thanemendation usual, after that. Sixteen couples on the floor at once, with a few dozen spectators scattered around, is calculated to have that effect in a brilliantly lighted parlor, I believe. Everything seemed to buzz, at any rate. After all the modern dances had been danced several times, the people adjourned to the supper-room. I found my wardrobe out there, as usual, with the Unreliable in it. His old distemper was upon him: he was desperately hungry. I never saw a man eat as much as he did in my life. I have the various items of his supper here in my note-book. First, he ate a plate of sandwiches; then he ate a handsomely iced poundcake; then he gobbled a dish of chicken salad; after which he ate a roast pig; after that, a quantity of blanc-mangeemendation; then he threwemendation in several glasses of punch to fortify his appetite, and finished his monstrous repast with a roast turkey. Dishes of brandy-grapes, and jellies, and such things, and pyramids of fruits, melted away before him as shadows fly at the sun's approach. I am of the opinion that none of his ancestors were present when the five thousand were miraculously fed in the old Scriptural times. I base my opinion upon the twelve baskets of scraps and the little fishes that remained over after that feastexplanatory note. If the Unreliable himself had been there, the provisions would just about have held out, I think.

After supper, the dancing was resumed, and after awhile, the guests [begin page 197] indulged in music to a considerable extent. Mrs. J. sang a beautiful Spanish song; Miss R., Miss T., Miss P., and Miss S., sang a lovely duetttextual note; Horace Smith, Esq., sang “I'm sitting on the stile, Mary,”explanatory note with a sweetness and tenderness of expression which I have never heard surpassed; Col. Musser sang “From Greenland's Icy Mountains” so fervently that every heart in that assemblage was purified and made better by it; Mrs. T. and Miss C., and Mrs. T. and Mrs. G. sang “Meet me by moonlight alone” charmingly; Judge Dixsonexplanatory note sang “O, Charming May” with great vivacity and artistic effect; Joe Wintersexplanatory note and Hal Claytonexplanatory note sang the Marseilles Hymn in French, and did it well; Mr. Wassonexplanatory note sang “Call me pet names” with his usual excellence—(Wasson has a cultivated voice, and a refined musical taste, but like Judge Brumfieldexplanatory note, he throws so much operatic affectation into his singing that the beauty of his performance is sometimes marred by it—I could not help noticing this fault when Judge Brumfield sang “Rock me to sleep, mother;”)emendation Wm. M. Gillespieexplanatory note sang “Thou hastemendation textual note wounded the spirit that loved thee,” gracefully and beautifully, and wept at the recollection of the circumstance which he was singing about. Up to this time I had carefully kept the Unreliable in the back ground, fearful that, under the circumstances, his insanity would take a musical turn; and my prophetic soulexplanatory note was right; he eluded me and planted himself at the piano; when he opened his cavernous mouth and displayed his slanting and scattered teeth,emendation the effect upon that convivial audience was as if the gates of a graveyard, with its crumbling tombstones, had been thrown open in their midst; then he shouted some thing about he “would not live alway”—and if I ever heard anything absurd in my life, that was it. He must have made up that song as he went along. Why, there was no more sense in it, and no more music, than there is in his ordinary conversation. The only thing in the whole wretched performance that redeemed it for a moment, was something about “the few lucid moments that dawn on us here.” That was all right; because the “lucid moments” that dawn on that Unreliable are almighty few, I can tell you. I wish one of them would strike him while I am here, and prompt him to return my valuables to me. I doubt if he ever gets lucid enough for that, though. After the Unreliable had finished squawking, I sat down to the piano and sang—however, what I sang is of no consequence to anybody. It was only a graceful little gem from the horse opera.

[begin page 198]

At about two o'clock in the morning the pleasant party broke up and the crowd of guests distributed themselves around town to their respective homes; and after thinking the fun all over again, I went to bed at four o'clock. So, having been awake forty-eight hours, I slept forty-eight,emendation in order to get even again, which explains the proposition I began this letter with.

Yours, dreamily,

Mark Twain.

Editorial Emendations Letter from Carson City
  Governor (I-C)  ●  Gover[n]or
  manner (I-C)  ●  m[a]nner
  house, (I-C)  ●  house[.]
  life (I-C)  ●  li[f]e
  don't (I-C)  ●  don‸t
  fellow (I-C)  ●  [f]ellow
  entirely (I-C)  ●  ent[i]rely
  than (I-C)  ●  t[h]an
  blanc-mange (I-C)  ●  blanc- | mange
  threw (I-C)  ●  [t]hrew
  mother;”) (I-C)  ●  mother;”‸
  hast (I-C)  ●  has
  teeth, (I-C)  ●  teeth[,]
  forty-eight, (I-C)  ●  forty-eight.
Textual Notes Letter from Carson City
 who he meant it for] The grammatical lapse is almost certainly authorial. Fourteen years later Clemens was still uncertain about the words, for he wrote Orion that he called his new lecture “ ‘Reminiscences of Some Pleasant Characters whom I have Met.’ (If ‘whom’ is bad grammar, scratch it out.)” (27 June 1871, CL3 , letter 64). Since the error is inseparable from Clemens' informal, colloquial style, we have not emended.
 duett] Contemporary American dictionaries recognized only “duet” and the Italian “duetto,” but the Oxford English Dictionary lists both “duet” and “duett.” Thus although the compositor may have mistakenly doubled the t or dropped the o, we have not emended.
 Thou hast] Copy-text “Thou has” is probably a compositorial error. Since the words occur in a song title within quotation marks, and since Clemens intends no gaff here (he is about to contrast the other singers with the “squawking” of the Unreliable), we have emended.
Explanatory Notes Letter from Carson City
 Joseph T. Goodman] Proprietor and senior editor of the Enterprise. Goodman came to California in 1854. With Denis McCarthy he purchased the Enterprise in 1861 and remained with the paper until 1874. He became a stockbroker in San Francisco and later a farmer in Fresno County (Goodman to A. B. Nye, 6 November 1905, A. B. Nye Collection, Bancroft). In 1897 Goodman published The Archaic Maya Inscriptions, the outcome of a long-standing interest in Central American archaeology.
 Silver City] A mining town in Gold Canyon just below Devil's Gate and south of Gold Hill, about halfway between Virginia City and Dayton (Angel, History, p. 502; Collins, Mercantile Guide, p. 313).
 Spring Valley] An area within the Devil's Gate mining district that lay to the south of Silver City not far from Empire City (“Our Washoe Correspondence, Letter from Dan De Quille,” Golden Era 11 [27 September 1863]: 8; “A Slight Mistake,” Virginia City Evening Bulletin, 31 October 1863, p. 3).
 Governor J. Neely Johnson's] Johnson served as California's fourth governor from 1856 to 1858. He moved to Nevada in 1860, practiced law in Carson City, represented Ormsby County in the Nevada constitutional conventions of 1863 and 1864, and served as a justice of the state supreme court from 1867 to 1871. Clemens gave him a prominent place in his burlesque address to the Third House of the 1863 Nevada Constitutional Convention, delivered on December 11. And in 1905 Clemens included him among the “unforgettable antiques” of his Nevada days ( MTEnt , pp. 105, 228; Clemens to Robert Fulton, 24 May 1905, MTL , 2:773).
 Horace Smith] A former mayor of Sacramento, Smith was a well-liked and successful Carson City lawyer. In December 1863 he died of gunshot wounds received during a quarrel over payment he claimed for the sale of his shares in the Yellow Jacket mine (Angel, History, p. 345; “The Shooting of Horace Smith,” Sacramento Union, 31 October 1863, p. 2).
 Col. Musser] John J. Musser was an original settler of Carson City in 1858. He was president of the convention that met in July 1859 in Genoa, Utah Territory, to frame a constitution for the proposed Territory of Nevada. Later that year, having been selected delegate to Washington, D.C., he unsuccessfully urged Congress to establish the new territory. In May 1863 he became prosecuting attorney for the Second Judicial District of Nevada. Clemens satirized him in the burlesque Third House address (Kelly, First Directory, p. 31; Angel, History, p. 335; Mack, History, pp. 181, 183–184; MTEnt , p. 108).
 Washoe City] Laid out in 1860 on the shores of Little Washoe Lake, this settlement quickly became the largest town in Washoe Valley and remained the Washoe County seat until 1871. During the 1860s the city was the major supplier of timber for the Comstock mines, as well as of fuel, food, and water for the people of Virginia City and other nearby mining towns. Washoe City was also the site of several large orereduction mills (“The Water Power at Washoe City,” Washoe City Times, 28 February 1863, p. 4; Angel, History, p. 646; Ratay, Pioneers, pp. 347–413).
 when we went out there to report the proceedings of the Convention] After the 1862 Territorial Legislature adjourned in Carson City on December 20, Clemens and Rice— who had reported it for their respective papers— took the stage to Washoe City to help celebrate the adjournment. In a letter to the Enterprise dated December 23, Clemens termed the festivities “a Grand Bull Drivers' Convention” that had assembled the day before to greet the returning Washoe County legislators (“A Big Thing in Washoe City,” reprinted from the Enterprise by the Placer County [Calif.] Courier, 17 January 1863, p. 3; quoted in MTNev , pp. 224–227). The notion of conventions held by Nevada bull drivers was apparently a public joke which Clemens drew upon (see “Wo-Haw!” Placer County [Calif.] Courier, 13 September 1862, p. 3).
 “half-a-man-left,”] That is, “allemande left,” a common step in the quadrille in which the man turns his partner on the left.
 the five thousand . . . that feast] Compare Mark 6:42–44.
 “I'm sitting on the stile, Mary,”] The first line of “Irish Emigrant's Lament,” music by William R. Dempster and words by Helen S. Sheridan. A humorous song entitled “Yankee Sarahnade” by “Samuel Slocum of Goslin Run,” which begins with the same line, is pasted in Scrapbook 1 (p. 76, MTP). Other songs mentioned in this paragraph are “From Greenland's Icy Mountains,” music by Lowell Mason and words by Reginald Heber; “Meet Me by Moonlight Alone,” music and words by Joseph Augustine Wade; “The Marseilles Hymn,” by Claude Joseph Rouget de Lisle; “Call Me Pet Names,” music by Charles Jarvis and words by Frances Mary Osgood; “Rock Me to Sleep, Mother,” music by J. Max Mueller and words by Elizabeth Akers Allen (Clemens parodied it in “An Important Question Settled,” Cincinnati Evening Chronicle, 9 March 1868, p. 3); “Thou Hast Wounded the Spirit That Loved Thee,” words and music by Mrs. Porter; “I Would Not Live Always,” music by George Kingsley and words by William A. Muhlenberg. The correct reading of the penultimate line in this last song, which Clemens distorts to “the few lucid moments that dawn on us here,” is “the few lurid mornings that dawn on us here.” “O, Charming May” could be an English translation of Mendelssohn's “Maienlied,” op. 8, no. 7, or of Mozart's “Komm' Lieber Mai,” or of Schumann's “Im Wunderschönen Monat Mai.” Clemens' own “little gem from the horse opera” was almost certainly “I Had an Old Horse Whose Name Was Methusalem,” the routine at the piano he sometimes used to enliven private gatherings and eventually to introduce his lectures (see MTEnt , pp. 49, 219 section 4 n. 5). On 25 August 1866 Clemens wrote his “oldest friend,” William Bowen: “Do you recollect the old hoss that died in the wilderness? I have made that famous in Washoe” ( CL1 , letter 109).
 Judge Dixson] E. C. Dixson was justice of the peace in Carson City (1861) and later (1861–1863) probate judge, and then commissioner, of Ormsby County. He represented Lander County in the third Territorial Legislature, January to February 1864. Clemens occasionally satirized him in his legislative reports (Carson City Silver Age, 13 July 1861, p. 1; Angel, History, p. 529; MTEnt , p. 168).
 Joe Winters] Clemens' acquaintance Joseph Winters of Carson City migrated from Illinois to California in 1848 and engaged in placer mining and freighting with his brothers John D. and Theodore Winters. He made a fortune from his early Comstock stake, which became part of the Ophir claim. Later he was an owner of the Aurora mill near Dayton, and like his brother Theodore he became prominent, for a time, in the racing circles of Nevada and California (“Lucky,” Reese River Reveille, supplement, 21 November 1863, p. 1; “ ‘Mark Twain's’ Letter,” San Francisco Morning Call, 15 July 1863, p. 1; Angel, History, pp. 56, 57, 67, 503; Bancroft, Works, 25:101–102; Ratay, Pioneers, pp. 293, 296, 299, 300, 325 n. 14).
 Hal Clayton] P. H. Clayton was an early settler in Carson City who became prosecuting attorney there in 1860. Early in 1863 he helped organize the Democratic party in Nevada and was arrested the following July for making disloyal statements, an episode that evidently did not detract from his professional success or personal popularity: repeatedly during the 1860s he presided over the convivial Third House. Clemens remembered him with fondness in 1905 when recalling the good old days in Nevada (Angel, History, pp. 73, 265, 551; MTEnt , pp. 100–101, 226; MTL , 2:773).
 Mr. Wasson] A native of New York State, Warren H. Wasson first crossed the plains in his early teens in 1849; he came to Nevada in 1857. He was a man of unusual versatility: miner, rancher, organizer of the provisional territorial government of Nevada (1859), United States marshal of Nevada Territory, an effective and intelligent Indian agent for many years, assessor of internal revenue for Nevada (1862–1869), holder of military commissions, and Ormsby County delegate to the November 1863 Nevada Constitutional Convention. Clemens first knew Wasson in the spring of 1862 while prospecting in Esmeralda County (Clemens to Orion Clemens, 13 April 1862, CL1 , letter 47; Clemens to Orion Clemens, [24 April 1862], CL1 , letter 49; Angel, History, pp. 81, 166–168, 533–534).
 Judge Brumfield] W. H. Brumfield, a prominent attorney in Carson City, was also assemblyman from Ormsby County in the second and third territorial legislatures (1862 and 1864). In February 1864 Clemens praised him as an “intelligent, industrious and upright” representative ( MTEnt , p. 165; Angel, History, pp. 334, 529).
 Wm. M. Gillespie] Clemens' good friend William Martin Gillespie came to Virginia City in 1861 from New York State. As clerk of the first Territorial Legislature and secretary of the Nevada constitutional conventions of 1863 and 1864, Gillespie worked closely with Clemens and other legislative reporters. He was dubbed “Jefferson's Manual” by Clemens because of his knowledge of parliamentary rules (“Legislative Proceedings. House— Thirty-first Day,” dated Carson, 11 February 1864, Scrapbook 3, p. 106, MTP). The two men also worked together when Clemens reported the First Annual Fair of the Washoe Agricultural, Mining and Mechanical Society, held in October 1863 in Carson City. Gillespie was deputy clerk of Storey County in 1863. He represented his county as delegate to the third Territorial Legislature and to the constitutional conventions of 1863 and 1864. Throughout Clemens' legislative reports, Gillespie is the object of good-natured chaffing (Kelly, Second Directory, p. 215; Angel, History, pp. 81, 86; MTEnt , pp. 81, 228).
 my prophetic soul] Hamlet, act 1, scene 5, line 40.