To
Oliver Wendell Holmes 30 September 1869 • Buffalo, N.Y.(MS: DLC, UCCL00360)
editorial rooms of “the express,”
buffalo,
Sept. 30 18 69.
Dear Mr. Holmes—
If I can get my pen to go along over this new-fangled cobble-stone paper without kicking
up behind, (which I
wish I had the author of it here,) I will acknowledge the receipt of your note & thank
you heartily for your good
words.1explanatory note
Since you would like to know what excuse I had for sending you so large a book, Mr
Holmes, I can easily furnish
a good one. I
have had Ⓐemendationread the “Autocrat of the Breakfast Table” two or three times already, when a superior
young lady requested
me a short time ago to read it again & mark it & marginal-note it all the way through for
her., (Young ladies like that sort of thing)—they are the parties that damage the library
books—& I did. Then I said in my secret soul, I have got a chance at this gentleman who
writes Autocrats of
Breakfast Tables & gives me extra work to do, & I will hurl my six hundred & fifty
pages at him
if I “fetch” the State if I miss him & “fetch” the State house!
{N. B.—Elsie Venner is waiting to be marked—commission from the same party.}2explanatory note
But speaking seriously, I so enjoyed reading the Autocrat the third time that I gave imposed the
pleasant task upon myself of
redin red reading Ⓐemendationit again & marking it without a suggestion from anybody. {Mem.—Am in the habit of
marking books
for the party mentioned a while ago.} I hadn’t any real “excuse,” but I sent the book
just as
a sort of unobtrusive “Thank-you” Ⓐemendationfor having given me so much pleasure often & over again. That is honest, as sure as
I am
Yours Most Truly
Samℓ. L. Clemens
Textual Commentary
30 September 1869 • To
Oliver Wendell Holmes
• Buffalo, N.Y. • UCCL00360
Source text(s):
MS, Papers of Oliver Wendell Holmes, Library of Congress, Washington, D.C. (DLC).
I don’t see what excuse you had for sending me such a great big book, which would
have cost me ever
so many dollars, but I assure you it was very welcome in spite of that—more welcome
than you could have guessed it would be,
for independently of the pleasure I have had from your other writings, and the agreeable
recollection of your visit to my house in
company with Mr Locke, some parts of your travels had a very special interest for
me. I may mention especially your visits to Palestine
and Egypt. You looked at these two countries in a somewhat different way it is true,
from Dr Robinson, or
Lepsius, but I always like to hear what one of my fellow-countrymen who is not a Hebrew
scholar or a reader of hieroglyphics, but a
good humored traveller with a pair of sharp twinkling Yankee (in the broader sense)
eyes in his head, has to say about the things that
learned travellers often make unintelligible and sentimental ones ridiculous or absurd.
Not long ago I read Hepworth Dixon’s
book about the Holy Land and since that Lady Herbert’s. What a different way they
had of looking at things to be sure. I am
tolerably familiar with other books on the East and I have a large collection of stereographs
of Egypt and Palestine—one of
the largest I think that anybody has about here. So you can imagine with what curiosity
I followed you through scenes that were in a
certain sense familiar to me and read your familiar descriptions and frequently quaint
and amusing comments, from such an entirely
distinct and characteristic point of view.
I was rather surprised and much pleased to find how well your ship’s company got on
together. I had
an idea they got sick of each other. I once crossed the ocean with another human being
occupying the same stateroom—a
German, who was well enough, I don’t doubt—but didn’t I loathe the sight and smell
of him before our
forty two days passage was over!
Well, I hope your booksellers will sell a hundred thousand copies of your Travels—don’t
let them get hold of this letter for the rascals always print everything to puff their
books—private or not—which
is odious but take my word for it your book is very entertaining and will give a great
deal of pleasure.
Yours very truly
O W Holmes
Holmes alluded to: Edward Robinson (1794–1863), American philologist, geographer,
and biblical scholar,
author of Biblical Researches in Palestine, Mount Sinai and Arabia Petraea (1841); Karl Richard Lepsius
(1810–84), German explorer and philologist, author of a number of books on Egypt;
William Hepworth Dixon
(1821–79), English historian, author of The Holy Land (1865); and Mary Elizabeth Herbert
(1822–1911), Baroness Herbert of Lea, translator, novelist, travel writer, and religious
biographer, author of Cradle Lands (1867), an account of travels in Egypt and the Holy Land. Clemens and David Ross
Locke had visited
Holmes in Boston on 14 or 15 March 1869.
MS, Papers of Oliver Wendell Holmes, Library of Congress, Washington, D.C. (DLC).
L3 , 364–66.
it is not known when DLC acquired the MS.
More information on provenance may be found in Description of Provenanceclick to open link.