Explanatory Notes        Apparatus Notes ()

Source: University of California, Mark Twain Papers, The Bancroft Library, Berkeley | New York Public Library, Albert A. and Henry W. Berg Collection, New York ([CU-MARK NN-BGC])

Cue: "Your letter has"

Source format: "Transcript | MS"

Letter type: "[standard letter]"

Notes:

Last modified:

Revision History: AB

Published on MTPO: 2007

Print Publication: v4

MTPDocEd
To John Henry Riley
2 December 1870 • Buffalo, N.Y. (MS and transcript: CU-MARK and NN-B, UCCL 00547)

{Preserve this letter.}

Dear Riley:

Your letter has come, & I have “reflected.” I had already done that I emendation a good deal & so my mind is not altered.1explanatory note

You know right well that I would not have you depart a hair from any obligation, either for any money. The boundless emendationconfidence I have in you is born of un a conviction of your integrity in small as well as great things. I know plenty of men whose integrity I would trust to here, but not off yonder in Africa.

I do not want you to dishonor any obligation, but I want you to write instantly to the Alta & the other papers saying, “I am offered a rare opportunity to permanently better my fortunes, & therefore I have appointed so & so to be your correspondent in my place., provided you approve; otherwise please instruct me by return mail how next to proceed.”2explanatory note Of course you can elaborate this, but is the idea correct?—that is, providing there is nothing graver or more binding than usually exists between publisher & correspondent. If these publishers can discharge you when they please, just as I they can discharge their local reporter when they please, you are doing nothing wrong if you give them a fort-night’s warning & do all you can to leave your place satisfactorily supplied.

But if your understandings are stronger, you cannot thus give them notice, but you can ask them r as a perfectly reasonable favor, to release you with all convenient dispatch. None of these propositions of mine have in them any taint of dishonor.

As for Sutro, his big heart will simply jump up & say, “By — Riley, don’t stop a minute for my matters—if it’s the best thing for you I won’t stand in your way.”3explanatory note

That Cole & Carter will “rely on your aid” is an obligation only this far: if they can insure emendationyou better results than Africa offers emendationsome other field offers, then in a business way they are entitled to rely on your aid. If you are in debt to them for past favors not predicated tacitly upon your aid in this session, then you are in emendation morally bound. But in any case your simple request with sta averment that you see an unusually promising chance for you ought to secure their instant & cordial acquiescence.4explanatory note

As to your committees. By a vote, your committees can discharge you. By a vote they can decline to re-electemendation you, after all your long service. If they could greatly better themselves, it would not only be their fair & just policy to do one of these things, but their official duty to do it. But if I engage you to go to Africa for 3 or 6 months, w for wages, for me, I can not discharge you., till your time is up., no matter whether you suit me or not.

But take no snap judgment on the committees, either. Let them choose a clerk, & do you diligently instruct him while you get ready for Africa.5explanatory note

You have certain moral obligations resting upon you toward all these parties you have mentioned—& also some less strenuous business ones. But in both cases they are doubtless such as an earnestemendation request from you would cheerfully cancel.

Now I come to business.

This thing is the pet scheme of my life. As follows:

1. I to pay your passage both to & from the South African diamond fields.

2. You to skirmish, prof emendation prospect, work, travel, & take min t pretty minute notes, with hand & brain, for 3 or 6 months 3 months (or 5 or 6 if necessary,) I paying you a hundred dollars a month, for you to live on. {Not more, because sometimes I want you to have to sku shin like everything for a square meal—for experiences are the kind of book-material I want.}

3. If you should pick up $5,000 worth of diamonds, you (within the specified time,) you to pocket that.

4. If you should make more, (in any way whatever,) before returning here (either during or subsequent to the specified 3 or 6 months,) you to send me half of that surplus—after first securing your $5,000 all right.

5. You to overstay the 3 months on no other condition than that you pay me $5,000 a month in advance for each month so overstaid, & divide earnings with me beside!. {Oh, I guess you’d better come home for a while & persuade me to drop No. 5, at least.}

6. You to use these manifold-paper diaries & so that you can every day or every few days write two journals at once, & mail one to me & preserve the other carefully yourself.6explanatory note

7. You are to write no l emendation newspaper letters while gone, & write no private letters without taking care that their contents shall be kept out of print. {I emendationwant to lay all the ropes thoroughly & then spring this book on the public.} I don’t want other publishers to have a chance to come the usual pitiful game—i. e., come out with an opposition book which rides into grand prosperity on the tide of the other’s success, instead of falling still-born, as it would if left to itself.} This to be a secret expedition while in progress, but to be a frightfully celebrated one 6 months afterward, not only here but in every language on ear in civilized Europe.}

8.

8. You to come to my house at the end of your labors, & live with me, at $50 a month & board, (I to furnish the cigars,) from 4 to 12 months, till I have pumped you dry—for, the purpose of your diary is to keep you (as well as me,) bright & inspire your tongue every morning when you sit take a seat in my study. You are to talk one or two hours to me every day, & tell your story—& the rest of the day & night you can do what you please with—& at 3 P. M., I shall always quit work too. With your diary by me I shall be able to write without mistakes after you are gone out for walking or driving.

9. At no time within five years are you to write or publish a book about Africa or its diamond fields. {This will fool rival publishers, too.}


All the above is for my m emendation benefit. But some shall enure to you., in case you follow my plam planemendation. Thus:

1. You see an interesting part of the world, & one upon which the y emendation eyes of the wo whole world are gazing centred.

2. It don’t cost you a cent to go or come, nor give you a chance to starve while there.

3. It does give you a chance to pick up a fortune in 3 months—the very same chance that thousands would be glad to take at their own expense.

4. I should write the book as if I went through all these adventures myself—this in order to give it snap & freshness. But would begin the Chapter book by saying: “When Daniel de Foe wanted to know what life on a solitary island was like, & doubted whether he cou emendation was hardy enough to stand it himself, he sent the ingenious Robinson W. Crusoe; & when I wanted to know all about the wild life in the diamond fields & its fascinations, I sent the & could not go myself, I sent the ingenious Riley. Now Riley, having returned emendationfrom his pilgrimage, sits down night & after emendationnight & tells his story & when he has finished I set it down from memory—not getting the ex emendation not caring so much about the exact language as about the spirit of the narration, of course—but using his language when it suits me, & emendationwhen it suits me putting words of my own to his ideas, fancies & adventures—& just as often the one as the other. In all cases it is Riley speaking, whether the children of his mind appear in the clothing wherein they issued from the door of their nursery, or have doffed a cap or changed a stocking here & there. And to begin, Riley says: “I left New York on board, etc., etc., etc.”emendation

Do you see? And I’ll hurl in a parenthesis of my own, occasionally, in brackets,—a comment on you or descriptive remark or anecdote about you, or fancy portrait of you in various circumstances of the voyage or adventures in the mines—& do these things so emendationguilelessly that before the reader knows it he is perishing to see Riley.

Then my object is accomplished & my game’s made! Because thus I can slam you into the lecture field for life & secure you ten thousand dollars a year as long as you live, & all the idle time you want, to loaf & travel in or raise a family. I mention lecturing without any fears because you were born for the platform—you were intended to stand before an audience, & not smile or make a gesture, but simply talk quietly along in a conversational voice & fashion & make them deal out laughter & applause in avalanches. And I mention lecturing with no misgivings that you may object, for the reason that I do not take you to be a man either afraid or ashamed to undertake a responsibility which another man would dare.

I would want to “coach” you, thoroughly, drill you completely (for it took me 3 or 4 years to learn the dead sure tricks of the platform, but I could teach them to you in 3 or 4 weeks so that when you stepped on a stage you would not be wondering within yourself whether you were going to vanquish the audience, but would absolutely know you would do it.)

When you got to Boston or Philadelphia, (either you pleased,) I would introduce you to the audience (provided you wished it,) or follow you with a paragraph, & if it wasn’t a good advertisement I want to know why?

5. You should infallibly begin your lecture career at $75 to $150 a night, & in your second lecture season (with the same old lecture,) you should have engagements enough to keep you talking right along for seven months, if you wanted to.

6. In your “off” months you could travel to some quaint country & get up a new lecture about it, & issue a profitable book through my publisher, well aware that your celebrity would give it a great sale—but I’d rather that you went at my expense every time & let me have the book, old boy.

7. If you never lecture, & never make anything in the diamond land (over $0 $5,000emendation) you’ll not owe me anything. But if you do lecture, then you can pay me back your expenses, in your second or third season, provided your lecturing is the success I have promised it will be, but not otherwise.


Finally.

1. You don’t get a cent out of the book. But,

2. You may pick up $50,000 in the mines. And,

3. In 5 years of lecturing you shall receive $50,000 if you’ll lecture.

4.


Pull & all haul my scheme as you please—criticise as you will, it’s as sound as a drum—there isn’t a leak in it. I’m bound to make money out of it if you get back, & you are bound to make money lecturing if you will.

For the certain & assured prosperity of us both, there needs not to be a solitary (or solitaire) diamond in all Africa, & I am not—what we want is to tell in the book & on the platform how lively a time we have had emendation hunting for them.


But I ure urge emendationupon you, “Expedition’s the word!” Clear & out now, & let us publish the first book & take the richest cream & deliver the freshest & newest & most fascinating picture of this rush, & not come lagging in second or third or fourth, on a public sh ho◇ emendationwhose appetite has begun to lose its grand ravenousness. Now emendationis the time to start—strike while the iron is hot. Sail hence, New Year’s: emendation

10th Jan. arrive England.

30th  ″  ″  Natal.

Feb. Mch. Apl. in Africa.

Sail May 1, reach here June 30.

July, Aug., Sept., Oct., you talk & I write.

Nov., Dec. & Jan., the book in press & printing 50,000 copies before one is issued.; & all as ely as possible. Agents taking 50,000 subscriptions in the meantime. And in the meantime let them the publishers start scratch for all the oppositions books they want to—I’ll launch the Riley book Feb. 1, 1872, & sweep the world like a besom of destruction (if you know what that is.)7explanatory note

Feb. & March & April I’ll ¶ During Feb., I’ll drill you in your lecture.

March, Apl., May, June, July, send you traveling, if there’s nothing better to do, & let you get me another book & return & fill me up.

June, July, Aug & Sept., you talk & I write.

Middle of October, you begin & lecture till first of next April or May & then go to Cal & talk in San F at $1200 or $1500 a night.8explanatory note

There isn’t a solitary thing in this entire programme that cannot be carried out to the very letter , if you will lecture. I don’t say if you can, but if you will emendation. I’ll make you make some of the “humorous” lecturers very sick.

But hurry, now. There is no single moment of time to lose. If you could start now, it would be splendid—we’d gain a months—but I know you’ll have to have 2 or 3 weeks in which to fairly & honorably release yourself from your se existing business bu ties. Run emendationup here as soon as you can, & let’s talk it all over. Com

Commence, now, Riley, & post yourself as to expenses, & let me know. I say nothing about posting yourself about other matters needful for to know, because I know your habits of mind.

Hang it, I’ll have you so well known in 18 months that there will be no man so ignorant as to have to ask “Who is Riley?”—& that will stab Fitz Smythe to the ha heartemendation!9explanatory note

Answer.10explanatory note

Yr friend
Sam. L. Clemens.

P P. S. Mind you keep the secret absolutely. One don’t have such a valuable one entrusted to him every day.

P.S. If you couldn’t, I had my eye on Dan de Quille, but I sort of doubt if poor old Dan could take a right big interest in anything, now.11explanatory note

Private. | J. H. Riley, Esq | P. O. Box 75 | Washington | D. C.| {Please return to | Sam. L. Clemens, | Buffalo, if it miscarries. postmarked: buffalo n.y. emendation dec 3

Textual Commentary
2 December 1870 • To John Henry RileyBuffalo, N.Y.UCCL 00547
Source text(s):

MS, Mark Twain Papers, The Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley (CU-MARK), is copy-text for ‘{Preserve . . . course—’ (258.1–261.11) and ‘7. If . . . now.’ (262.14–264.4). Where MS is missing—‘but . . . boy.’ (261.11–262.13)—copy-text is John Henry Riley’s MS transcription of the letter, Henry W. and Albert A. Berg Collection, The New York Public Library, Astor, Lenox and Tilden Foundations (NN-B). Clemens’s MS envelope, also at NN-B, is copy-text for ‘Private. . . . dec 3’ (264.6–12).

Previous Publication:

L4 , 258–66; MTB , 1:423, paraphrase and brief excerpt; AAA 1925, lot 108a, paraphrase and brief excerpts (from transcription and envelope); Underhill, 18 (transcription); AAA/Anderson 1936, lot 120, paraphrase and brief excerpts (transcription and envelope); MTLP , 46–52.

Provenance:

for the letter MS, see Mark Twain Papers in Description of Provenance. The transcription and envelope were sold in 1924, 1925, and 1936 (AAA 1924, lot 93, and 1925, lot 108a; AAA/Anderson 1936, lot 120). Until his death in 1939 they were owned by W. T. H. Howe; in 1940, the Howe Collection was purchased by Dr. Albert A. Berg and donated to NN (Cannon, 185–86).

More information on provenance may be found in Description of Provenanceclick to open link.

Explanatory Notes
1 

Clemens responded to the following letter (CU-MARK):

jr

Friend Clemens

Last night I dreamed “three times in succession” that I dwelt and delved in the Diamond fields of South Africa, and fairly reveled in the Republic of the Transvaal (wherever that may be)—furthermore that that I had been eminently successful in finding and buying the precious gems, some of which outrivalled the Koh-i-nor in size, weight and water, and outshone the Great Hoggarty Diamond in brilliancy. And lo and behold, this morning comes your letter!

How I would have liked to have been able to pack right up and start from the word “go”. I am “mighty willin” but not ready. And so after duly considering the subject, and carefully weighing the pros and cons I telegraphed the following “at your expense”:—

“Yes—at the close of session. Will write. Would rather talk. Pass is good yet. Can start to-morrow evening. Shall I? Answer”. Charges $1.50 for that with orders to C.O.D.

Waiting a reply I am writing you, with thanks for your kind consideration for my welfare and assuring you that I would really like to go. I am somewhat of an expert in precious stones, thanks to that poor old Brazillian Diamond Hunter whom I befriended in the Cal. mines, years ago; have a taste that way and thanks to my early experience in the gold fields and in Mexico and Centro-America am a good campaigner and know how to take care of myself and others. Besides which a residence of five years in the District of Columbia should certainly fit a man for South Africa. North Africa or the Interior of Africa. All of which is respectfully submitted. But—why did the idea not enter into your head or my head, or the pair of cabbage-heads when I was with you in Buffalo? And I would have said Yes to your query “Will You Go?” at once. Now, I consider that I am to a certain extent compromised to remain here through this session for I know that Senator Cole, Sutro, Judge Carter and others will rely upon my aid in their matters and apart from my engagement with the Alta I have agreed to correspond with two other Cal. newspapers during the session; and this only one short week ago.

Then there are my two Committees—before which there remains much unfinished business which “went over” during the last session—and with which no new man taking my place as Clerk, could attend to so well as I, and it would not be right for me to leave at this time. Were I to go to Africa, to the diamond fields, or to Peru, to the coal mines, for you, I am sure you would not like me to fly off somewhere else just because the impulse seized me or a better offer were made me to go elsewhere. No—I cannot do it even though to “stick” should result to my disadvantage. But if there is no actual haste in the matter I can go after close of the session say as soon as you like after the fourth of March next. Who cares if there are “four hundred waggons on the Pnielside”. Why when I get there with my waggon I’ll drive in on the near side or the off side and thus secure a positive advantage—especially when it is time to leave. So wait for the “Ides of March” or fix a date to correspond to ’em, and I’ll go.

Yours truly
J. H. Riley.

Your injunction of secresy is heeded most religiously.


Riley had come to Buffalo on 30 October, registering at the Mansion House hotel (“Hotel Arrivals,” Buffalo Express, 31 Oct 70, 4). Pniel, South Africa, was about thirty miles east of Cape Town.

2 

Riley chose George Alfred Townsend to assume his San Francisco Alta California correspondence, and perhaps his other, unidentified, newspaper commitments as well. Townsend (1841-1914), by this time a playwright, poet, biographer, and lecturer, had been a Civil War correspondent for the New York Herald and the New York World, and, since 1867, Washington correspondent of the Chicago Tribune, the Cincinnati Enquirer, and other papers. His letters were highly regarded for their humor, wisdom, and keen observation. He, Riley, and Clemens had shared a house in Washington during the winter of 1867–68 (Riley to SLC, 6 Dec 70, 31 Dec 70, CU-MARK; “G. A. Townsend, Journalist, Dead,” New York Times, 16 Apr 1914, 9; L2 , 196 n. 1).

3 

Adolph Sutro (1830–98), another mutual friend of Clemens and Riley’s, was in Washington in December 1870 to protect and advance his congressional franchise, granted in July 1866, to build a tunnel through Mount Davidson in Nevada to facilitate access to the Comstock lode. Construction had begun in October 1869 and the main tunnel was completed in 1878. Two years later Sutro sold his shares in the Sutro Tunnel Company and turned his attention to real estate investments in San Francisco (see RI 1993 , 684–85). As clerk to the House Committee on Mines and Mining, Riley was well placed to be of assistance to Sutro (Adolph Sutro, 31–32).

4 

Cornelius Cole, senator from California, was an acquaintance of Clemens’s (6 July 70 to OLC, n. 1click to open link). He served on the Senate Committee on Appropriations and the Senate Committee on Public Buildings and Grounds, neither of which employed Riley as clerk (Poore: 1870, 56, 57, 67; 1871, 57, 58, 68). “Carter” probably was David Kellogg Cartter (1812–87), chief justice of the Supreme Court of the District of Columbia since 1863.

5 

Riley was anxious to arrange his clerkships before the convening of the third session of the Forty-first Congress (5 Dec 70–3 Mar 71), but did not complete his arrangements until after the session had begun. By the end of December he had turned his clerkship of the House Committee on Mines and Mining, and possibly his second, unidentified clerkship, over to still another of his and Clemens’s mutual friends, James Rankin Young, former head of the New York Tribune’s Washington bureau, now correspondent for the New York Standard and two Philadelphia papers, the Post and the Star ( L3 , 228, 230 n. 6; BDUSC , 187; Riley to SLC, 31 Dec 70, CU-MARK; Boyd 1871, 387; Poore: 1870, 122; 1871, 128).

6 

Riley’s surviving notes are carbon copies torn from such a diary (3 Mar 71 to Riley, n. 1click to open link).

7 

A broom, as in “I will also make it a possession for the bittern, and pools of water: and I will sweep it with the besom of destruction, saith the Lord of hosts” (Isaiah 14:23).

8 

Clemens had earned about sixteen hundred dollars when he lectured in San Francisco on 14 April 1868 ( L2 , 209 n. 2).

9 

Evidently Riley shared Clemens’s antagonism toward Albert S. Evans (“Fitz Smythe”): see 28 Jan 70 to Bliss, n. 1click to open link.

10 

Riley first responded on Monday, 5 December, with a telegram that Clemens received the following day: “Long letter rec’d Plan approved Will get ready to go” (CU-MARK). On 6 December he sent a follow-up letter, tentatively accepting Clemens’s invitation to Buffalo: “I shall try and get leave of absence till Monday next, and in the event of succeeding will start to-morrow (Wednesday) or say Thursday evening, at furthest, so that you may look for me at the Mansion House on Thursday or Friday night—to return on Monday next. I guess when I’m all ready to start for Buffalo, I’ll telegraph you to that effect” (CU-MARK). Instead Riley and Clemens met in New York City around 14 December (13 Dec 70click to open link, 20 Dec 70, both to Blissclick to open link).

11 

William Wright (Dan De Quille) may have been incapacitated by the alcoholism that occasionally resulted in his temporary imprisonment and discharge from the Virginia City Territorial Enterprise (Doten 1973; 2:1071, 1087, 1119). Joseph T. Goodman had probably informed Clemens of Wright’s circumstances. Goodman and Clemens clearly were corresponding in 1870, but except for a paraphrase of one of Clemens’s letters (28? Sept 70 to Goodmanclick to open link) the correspondence has not been found.

Emendations and Textual Notes

MS is copy-text for ‘{Preserve . . . course—’ (258.1–261.11)

  I  ●  partly formed
  boundless ●  boundeesless
  insure  ●  insussre underscore added after revision
  Africa offers  ●  false ascenders/descenders
  in  ●  ‘i’ partly formed
  re-elect ●  re- | elect
  earnest ●  ear- | rnest
  prof prospect ●  profspect canceled ‘f’ partly formed
  l  ●  partly formed
  print. {I ●  print.— | {I
  m  ●  partly formed; possibly n or w
  plam plan ●  plamn
  y  ●  partly formed
  cou  ●  ‘u’ partly formed
  returned ●  returened
  night & after ●  sic
  ex  ●  ‘x’ partly formed Transcript is copy-text for ‘but . . . boy.’ (261.11–262.13)
  & ●  and also at 261.13 (twice), 16, 21, 23, 24, 25 (twice), 28, 29 (three times); 262.3, 6, 9, 10, 12
  “I . . . etc.” ●  ‘I . . . etc.’”
  so ●  a so MS is copy-text for ‘7. If . . . dec 3 (262.14–264.4)
  $0 $5,000 ●  $05,000
  have had ●  haved
  ure urge  ●  urege
  ho◇  ●  possibly ha◇
  ravenousness. Now  ●  ravenousness.— | Now
  Years:  ●  deletion implied
  will  ●  possibly will
  ties. Run ●  ties.— | Run
  ha heart ●  haeart
  buffalo n.y.  ●  buffalo ◇◇ y badly inked
Top