Explanatory Notes        Apparatus Notes ()

Source: Collection of John L. Feldman ([Mn2])

Cue: "I thank you very much"

Source format: "MS"

Letter type: "[standard letter]"

Notes:

Last modified:

Revision History: AB

Published on MTPO: 2007

Print Publication: v6

MTPDocEd
To Josiah G. Holland
29 April 1875 • Hartford, Conn. (MS: Feldman, UCCL 01266)
slc/mt                        farmington avenue, hartford.

I thank you very much for the compliment of the offer, but I am not a capable person for the work, even if I had the time. There is probably not another man in Connecticut who is so besottedly ignorant of Hartford as I am. I have lived here 3 or 4 years (in the fringe of the city) & I only go down town when it is necessary to abuse my publisher.

In the absence of Chas. Dudley Warner, I would suggest his firstassistant, Chas. Clark, of the Courant, as the best man.2explanatory note

Very Truly Yrs
Sam L. Clemens
Textual Commentary
29 April 1875 • To Josiah G. HollandHartford, Conn.UCCL 01266
Source text(s):

MS facsimile. The editors have not seen the MS, which was owned in 1990 by John L. Feldman, who provided a copy to the Mark Twain Papers.

Previous Publication:

L6 , 470–71.

Explanatory Notes
1 

Clemens answered the following letter (CU-MARK):

editorial rooms of scribner’s monthly, 743 broadway, new york.

My dear Sir:—

I wish to put Hartford into a series of articles on American cities which have already been commenced in “Scribner.” I can use such pictures as I need from the Colt memorial volume, and make the rest. Can you write the article, or, rather, will you write it? If so, please let me know what buildings and scenes ought to be represented, so that I may send up a man to look after the matter. It is not often that a writer is invited into our magazine, with his place of residence. But a jewel in its appropriate setting is so much more desirable! Please let me hear from you at your earliest convenience, and, if the service I ask of you seems impracticable, tell me who the next best man is.

Yours very Truly
J. G. Holland

On the envelope Clemens noted, “From Dr. J. G. Holland, (‘Timothy Titcomb’) poet & editor of Scribner’s Monthly.” Holland alluded to Armsmear: The Home, the Arm, and the Armory of Samuel Colt. A Memorial, by Henry Barnard (New York: Alvord, 1866). Only one city had as yet been covered in Scribner’s illustrated series: “The Liverpool of America” (Baltimore), by Edward King, in the April issue. Later in 1875, two more articles appeared: “The City of the Golden Gate,” by Clemens’s San Francisco Evening Bulletin friend Samuel Williams, in July, and “Chicago,” by J. W. Sheahan, in September (9:681–95; 10:266–85, 529–51). Clemens was not favorably disposed toward Holland: in 1872 he had written a scathing rebuttal—which he never published—to Holland’s attacks on platform humorists (see L5 , 77–78 n. 1, 122–24 n. 5; L2 , 209).

2 

Warner was abroad. Charles Hopkins Clark (1848–1926) graduated from Yale in 1871 and joined the staff of the Courant that same year. He became known for his public spirit, promoting civic improvement with clear, cogent, and sometimes humorous editorials. Holland presumably followed Clemens’s suggestion, since Clark contributed a twenty-page article on Hartford, “The Charter Oak City,” to Scribner’s Monthly for November 1876. He later wrote three other pieces on Hartford—“The Growth of the County,” “Insurance,” and “The Press”—for J. Hammond Trumbull’s 1886 Memorial History of Hartford County (Charles Hopkins Clark 1876, 1886 [bib13419], 1886 [bib13420], 1886 [bib13421]; Burpee, 2:674, 3:26–29; McNulty, 101).

Top