I don’t know whether this is old or new. Joe Twichell got it from a Cleveland clergyman,
who said it was very recent. If you print it, put it where I have marked it in the
proof, & send a proof of
it to Canada & forward one to me for London. If it is too powerful, squelch it & let
me have the
MS again.1
Some Simsburg ass printed the story of Daniel in the Lion’s Den yesterday in the Hartford
Times, & did it so wretchedly & nastily & witlessly that I suppose the whole nation
of
Helen’s Baby’s admirers will welcome it as a very inspiration of humor & read
& copy it everywhere.2
Your visit was entirely too short. I do hope you will all be able to make a long one
when you come
in December. We’ll make Johnny & Winnie enjoy it.3
This tribe sends loving regards to yours.
Mrs. Gilman has fitful glimmerings of reason, in which she straightway plunges into
schemes for
paying the swindled creditors, & is soon a frantic maniac again.4
Explanatory Notes
1 Clemens intended his enclosed manuscript to be inserted in the final installment of
“Some Rambling Notes of an Idle Excursion,” forthcoming in the January 1878
Atlantic Monthly. The proposed addition was “The Invalid’s Story,” about a mix-up involving a corpse
in a coffin, a crate of rifles, and “a box of very eloquent Limburger cheese.” Howells
rejected it. In 1879 Clemens meant to use it in
A Tramp Abroad, but refrained, again on advice from Howells (30 Jan 1879 to Howells, Letters 1876–1880).
Finally, in 1882, he inserted a revised version of it in “Some Rambling Notes” when
he included that series in
The Stolen White Elephant, reporting that it had been left out of the
Atlantic printing “because it was feared that the story was not true, and at that time there
was no way of proving that it was not” (
SLC 1877–82;
SLC 1882b, 94–95).
2 In a letter dated 29 October 1877, printed in the Hartford
Times on 31 October (“Ending Mark Twain’s ‘Captain’s Story,’ in His Trip to the Bermudas,
No. II”). Frank Jewett, of Simsbury, Connecticut tried “to make amends” for Clemens’s
alleged “short-comings” in the second installment of
“Some Rambling Notes,” in the November issue of the
Atlantic. Claiming to have sailed from Boston in 1843 in a “staunch barque” under the command
of Captain “Hurricane” Jones—the fictional mariner featured in Twain’s sketch, based
on the prototype of Captain Edgar Wakeman—Jewett corroborated the captain’s penchant
for offering inventive explanations of Biblical miracles, but insisted that “Mark
did not ‘tell it all.’” According to Jewett, Jones often told the story of Isaac and
the prophets of Baal in conjunction with that of Daniel in the lions’ den; the
Atlantic sketch, however, included only the former. Jewett’s long-winded rendition of the
Daniel story in the
Times closely paralleled the version told with greater economy and skill by Wakeman in
his memoir,
The Log of an Ancient Mariner (
Wakeman 1878, 253–54), confirming Jewett’s claim that he had heard the captain tell it firsthand.
3 The Howellses were in Hartford from 25 to 27 October (25 or 26 Oct? 1877 to Elinor
Howells, n. 1). Howells made a second visit, with his daughter Winifred, staying with
the Clemenses from 11 to around 15 December. While there he lectured twice, first
on Gibbon in Seminary Hall on Wednesday, 12 December, then on Venice the following
morning, at a special meeting of the Saturday Morning Club, Clemens’s young women’s
group (Howells to SLC, 23 Nov 1877,
CU-MARK;
MTHL, 1:209–10).
4 In early October 1877 the New York financial community was stunned by the revelation
that William C. Gilman (1833–1922), a highly regarded insurance broker, was guilty
of forgery. Gilman, who for years had been living beyond his income, “raised” the
denominations of insurance and bank stock certificates and then used them as collateral
for loans totaling more than $200,000, which he could not repay. On 12 October, after
several days in hiding, Gilman surrendered and confessed. Immediately convicted, he
was sentenced to five years’ imprisonment at hard labor (New York
Times: “Vast Forgeries Exposed,” 3 Oct 1877, 1; “The Gilman Forgeries,” 4 Oct 1877, 5;
“W. C. Gilman Indicted,” 12 Oct 1877, 8; “The Story of Gilman,” 13 Oct 1877, 4). The
case was of special interest in the Clemens household because Gilman’s wife, Catherine
(1836–79), was the sister of Clemens’s lawyer, Charles E. Perkins, and the niece of
the Reverend Henry Ward Beecher. She was admitted to the Hartford Retreat for the
Insane after her delusion that “her husband’s trouble was a great mistake” became
a “mania,” and at last she “became so violent” that her physician and friends “were
compelled to place her under restraint” (“Results of Gilman’s Crime,” New York
Tribune, 22 Oct 1877, 2;
“Nook Farm Genealogy” 1974, 5, 7, 22). Although she was released after several months, she never recovered completely,
and died on 1 December 1879. Her husband’s sentence was commuted shortly thereafter,
in time for him to attend her funeral (“Gilman, the Forger, Free,” New York
Sun, 4 Dec 1879, 1).
MS, MH-H, shelf mark bMS Am 1784 (98).
MTHL , 1:208–9.
See Howells Letters in Description of Provenanceclick to open link.