Explanatory Notes        Apparatus Notes ()

Source: Virginia City Territorial Enterprise, 1864.05.24 ([])

Cue: "I wrote you"

Source format: "Transcript"

Letter type: "[standard letter]"

Notes:

Last modified:

Revision History: AB

Published on MTPO: 2007

Print Publication: v1

MTPDocEd
To James L. Laird
21 May 1864 • Virginia City, Nev. Terr. (Virginia City Territorial Enterprise, 24 May 64, UCCL 02773)
Enterprise Office,

James Laird, EsqSir:—I wrote you a note this afternoon demanding a published retraction of insults that appeared in two articles in the Union of this morning—or satisfaction. I have since received what purports to be a reply, written by a person who signs himself “J. W. Wilmington,” in which he assumes the authorship and responsibility of one of said infamous articles.1explanatory note Mr. Wilmington is a person entirely unknown to me in the matter, and has nothing to do with it. In the columns of your paper you have declared your own responsibility for all articles appearing in it, and any farther attempt to make a catspaw of any other individual and thus shirk a responsibility that you had previously assumed will show that you are a cowardly sneak. I now peremptorily demand of you the satisfaction due to a gentleman—without alternative.

SAM. L. CLEMENSemendation.
Textual Commentary
21 May 1864 • To James L. LairdVirginia City, Nev. Terr.UCCL 02773
Source text(s):

“Personal Correspondence,” letter III, Virginia City, Territorial Enterprise, 24 May 64, clipping in Scrapbook 3:146, Moffett Collection, Mark Twain Papers, The Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley (CU-MARK).

Previous Publication:

L1 , 292; Benson, 183, reprinted from the Sacramento Union, 26 May 64, 2; MTEnt , 192.

Provenance:

see Moffett Collection, p. 462.

More information on provenance may be found in Description of Provenanceclick to open link.

Explanatory Notes
1 

Clemens had received the following response, not from Laird (who he presumed had written “The ‘How Is It’ Issue,” the Union’s 21 May editorial), but from the author of the “Printer” letter, which the paper published the same day:

Office of the Virginia Daily Union,

Samuel Clemens, Esq.—Mr. James Laird has just handed me your note of this date. Permit me to say that I am the author of the article appearing in this morning’s Union. I am responsible for it. I have nothing to retract. Respectfully,

J. W. WILMINGTON.

(Wilmington 1864, 3:146)

Emendations and Textual Notes
 Enterprise . . . 1864 ● a vertical brace spans the right margin of the place and date lines
 Office . . . 1864. ● a vertical brace spans the right margin of the place and date lines
  L. CLEMENS ●  L CLEMENS
Top